The algorithm has spoken, it prefers your uncle’s car forum

For decades, we in the marketing and PR world have operated on a few simple, comforting truths. We believed in the power of the polished press release, the perfectly optimised landing page, and the sort of corporate messaging that’s been so thoroughly focus-grouped it wouldn’t offend a milk bottle. We built our careers on it.

It’s a bit awkward, then, that the future has arrived and it seems to prefer unfiltered chaos.

A rather illuminating analysis from Search Engine Journal has revealed that the new AI search tools, often touted as harbingers of a sleek, automated tomorrow, are overwhelmingly citing Reddit as their most trusted source. Yes, Reddit. The internet’s sprawling, wonderful, and occasionally alarming village hall, where anonymous users debate everything from quantum physics to the correct way to stack a dishwasher.

It turns out that when people ask AI for advice, the AI doesn’t turn to a glossy corporate brochure. It turns to a thread started by “SoggyBiscuit42” complaining that his new car’s radio sounds like a trapped wasp. Why? Because, unlike us, SoggyBiscuit42 is considered a bastion of authenticity.

This presents a bit of a pickle. Customers, having been marinated in marketing spiel for half a century, have developed a perfectly rational allergy to it. They’ve realised that the truth is rarely found in an advertisement. And now, AI has realised it too.

So, what is a self-respecting PR professional to do? Wring our hands? Pen a strongly-worded memo? Or perhaps, just perhaps, adapt. For those of us who’ve long suspected that public relations should be more about genuine connection than message discipline, this is, frankly, rather good news.

Step One: A Bit of Strategic Eavesdropping

The first, and most crucial, step is to stop talking and start listening. The conversations happening on platforms like Reddit are what the article refers to as the “messy” customer journey. It’s where people admit they don’t know what they want, argue about the fundamentals, and eventually stumble towards a solution.

Our job is to tune into this glorious mess. It’s less about “data harvesting” and more about good old-fashioned eavesdropping. What are the real, niggling problems people have? What are the daft questions they’re too embarrassed to ask a salesperson? This is where you find the insights that matter.

Step Two: Earning Your Seat at the Table

You cannot simply stride into these communities with a logo and a list of key messages. It’s the conversational equivalent of a politician turning up at a music festival. It fools nobody and makes everyone feel a bit uncomfortable.

Authenticity is the only currency that has any value here, and it must be earned. This is the true art of PR. It’s not about planting stories; it’s about finding the genuine experts and enthusiasts and offering them something of actual value. Give them interesting information. Offer them access to your clever people. In short, be helpful, not loud.

Step Three: For Goodness’ Sake, Solve a Problem

Armed with these new insights, our output has to change. The world does not need another press release about “leveraging synergies to drive forward-thinking paradigms.” It might, however, appreciate a simple, well-written article explaining how to fix a common, irritating problem with your product.

This is how you build trust. You stop selling a solution and start actually solving the problem. You become a useful resource, not just another voice shouting for attention. When you do that, something remarkable happens. People start talking about you positively. And when they do, AI listens.

The great irony in all of this is that, after years of chasing algorithms, the secret to success appears to be simply behaving like a decent, helpful human being. The future of PR isn’t about outsmarting the machine; it’s about remembering how to have a proper conversation.

And frankly, it’s about time.

  • Paul Richardson

    Paul Richardson FCIM MCIPR is a marketing and PR specialist at Vividink, mainly working in the events and exhibitions industry.

We need your help

We believe the events industry deserves a central, independent space for news and resources that isn't hidden behind a paywall and is free of banner ads. At just £10 a month, you can help to ensure EPN Journal remains ad free and accessible to everyone in the event industry. We use Stripe for security and you can cancel any time.